Trump — American Gaullist

Trump — American Gaullist

This post was viewed 22,664 times.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Votes: 4.89 Stars!
Share Pat's Columns!

By Patrick J. Buchanan

If a U.S. president calls an adversary “Rocket Man … on a mission to suicide,” and warns his nation may be “totally destroyed,” other ideas in his speech will tend to get lost.

Which is unfortunate. For buried in Donald Trump’s address is a clarion call to reject transnationalism and to re-embrace a world of sovereign nation-states that cherish their independence and unique identities.

Western man has engaged in this great quarrel since Woodrow Wilson declared America would fight in the Great War, not for any selfish interests, but “to make the world safe for democracy.”

Our imperialist allies, Britain, France, Russia, Japan, regarded this as self-righteous claptrap and proceeded to rip apart Germany, Austria, Hungary and the Ottoman Empire and to feast on their colonies.

After World War II, Jean Monnet, father of the EU, wanted Europe’s nations to yield up their sovereignty and form a federal union like the USA.

Europe’s nations would slowly sink and dissolve in a single polity that would mark a giant leap forward toward world government — Alfred, Lord Tennyson’s “Parliament of man, the Federation of the world.”

Charles De Gaulle lead the resistance, calling for “a Europe of nation-states from the Atlantic to the Urals.”

For 50 years, the Gaullists were in constant retreat. The Germans especially, given their past, seemed desirous of losing their national identity and disappearing inside the new Europe.

Today, the Gaullist vision is ascendant.

“We do not expect diverse countries to share the same cultures, traditions, or even systems of government,” said Trump at the U.N.

“Strong sovereign nations let diverse countries with different values, different cultures, and different dreams not just coexist, but work side by side on the basis of mutual respect. …

“In America, we do not seek to impose our way of life on anyone, but rather to let it shine as an example for everyone to watch.”

Translation: We Americans have created something unique in history. But we do not assert that we should serve as a model for mankind. Among the 190 nations, others have evolved in different ways from diverse cultures, histories, traditions. We may reject their values but we have no God-given right to impose ours upon them.

Have something to say about this column?
Visit Pat's FaceBook page and post your comments….

It is difficult to reconcile Trump’s belief in self-determination with a National Endowment for Democracy whose reason for being is to interfere in the politics of other nations to make them more like us.

Trump’s idea of patriotism has deep roots in America’s past.

After the uprisings of 1848 against the royal houses of Europe failed, Lajos Kossuth came to seek support for the cause of Hungarian democracy. He was wildly welcomed and hailed by Secretary of State Daniel Webster.

But Henry Clay, more true to the principles of Washington’s Farewell Address, admonished Kossuth:

“Far better is it for ourselves, for Hungary, and for the cause of liberty that, adhering to our wise, pacific system, and avoiding the distant wars of Europe, we should keep our lamp burning brightly on the western shore as a light to all nations, than to hazard its utter extinction amid the ruins of fallen or falling republics in Europe.”

Trump’s U.N. address echoed Clay: “In foreign affairs, we are renewing this founding principle of sovereignty. Our government’s first duty is to its people … to serve their needs, to ensure their safety, to preserve their rights, and to defend their values.”

Trump is saying with John Quincy Adams that our mission is not to go “abroad in search of monsters to destroy,” but to “put America first.” He is repudiating the New World Order of Bush I, the democracy crusades of the neocons of the Bush II era, and the globaloney of Obama.

Trump’s rhetoric implies intent; and action is evident from Rex Tillerson’s directive to his department to rewrite its mission statement — and drop the bit about making the world democratic.

The current statement reads: “The Department’s mission is to shape and sustain a peaceful, prosperous, just, and democratic world.”

Tillerson should stand his ground. For America has no divinely mandated mission to democratize mankind. And the hubristic idea that we do has been a cause of all the wars and disasters that have lately befallen the republic.

If we do not cure ourselves of this interventionist addiction, it will end our republic. When did we dethrone our God and divinize democracy?

And are 21st-century American values really universal values?

Should all nations embrace same-sex marriage, abortion on demand, and the separation of church and state if that means, as it has come to mean here, the paganization of public education and the public square?

If freedom of speech and the press here have produced a popular culture that is an open sewer and a politics of vilification and venom, why would we seek to impose this upon other peoples?

For the State Department to declare America’s mission to be to make all nations look more like us might well be regarded as a uniquely American form of moral imperialism.

Do You Appreciate Reading Our
Emails and Website?
Let us know how we are doing –
Send us a Thank You Via Paypal!

Share Pat's Columns!
Tom Lancaster, Vicente Clark, Rich DiTeodoro, Paul Ward, Maxim Arcana, Donna M Pisto Harrison, Brian Pace, Cynthia J. Starks, Jule McHermit, Clifford Petersen, Scott Tapley, Wilton Knight, Tim Meshginpoosh, William Patterson, Sergei Nemtsov, Trina Leder Jenny, Matt Murphy, David Sali, Vic Minich Jr., Isaac Sweilem, Mykhailo Mykhailovich Susir, Eric Rogers, Daniel Ruiz Paredes, Jeff Stowell, Andrew Majewski, Danny R. Haught Jr., Elaine Callahan, Allen Sullivant, Steve Dowdy, Jeremy Bornstein, Mitsuo Nakai, Jack Hamilton, Xave Medley, Øyvind Eikrem, Stephen Kincheloe, Dennis Schiely, Panadechi Santiago, Rebecca Ewing, Nathan Antrim, Max W. Harrington, Johnny Robertson, Joshua Hendrickson, Bailey Webb, Chris Knapp, Robby Rieger, Mary Ann Settle, John Mullen, Alan M. Simmons, Jim Smith, Bernie Flynn, John Aiton, James Spielman, Fernando Cassinelli, James Brown Jr., Bill Keegan, George Walden, Bryan Parking, Nathan Schockman, Eugene Girin, Christina Lind Adams, Phil Caulfield, Bill Haft Jr., Beth Prohodski, Gunnar Skogsholm, Wm Eric Thomas, Stephen Smith, Bobby Taylor, Todd Garrison, Carl Phillips, John Crowley, Matthew C Sult, Carol Mihelic, Leo Buffalo, Robert Schneider, Robert Christian, Sal Battaglia, Travis White, Kathi Elizabeth, Jim Murphy, Matthew Bommarito, Eileen V Robinson, Stefan Radivoyevitch, Charles Parker, Enoch Strife, Cameron White, Gail Weber, Eric O'Neal, Robert Lewton, Barry Willis, Andy Wallace, Tim Miller, Lowren James, Michael Tumblety, John Richard Roberts, Blake Weyrich, Thorleif Persson, Bobbie Payton Pitman, David Brantley, Christopher Hussey, JJ Roman, Pat Buchanan - American, Mohamed Aboul-Seoud, Luis Obispo, Betty Clark Edwards, Scott Reynolds, Greg Mussitsch, John Petzoldt, Roy Keith Trawick, Mark Davison, Samuel Mcfadden, Steven Gilber, Matt Logan, Alexandra Bergmann, David Towers, Matt Lawlor, Lisa Ziegler Lawson, Mat Waites, Kate Jenkins, Mike Porter, Mary Blumreich, Chalco Hills, James Edmund Thomas Snow, James Bramer, Jean-Marie Mario Berg, Birgit Ulrich Davis, Саша Каретка, Mickey Long, Alan Lloyd, Laszlo Veres, Ken Satifka, Kevin Brady, Michael Noyes, Gary Boberg, Gale Barber, Michael Sandoz, Christopher Wooden, Will Peavy, Luis Ortiz, Tammy Tapley, Dory Shawver, Christian Evans, Joseph Franciscone, David Buchanan, Christopher Baker, Tim Hitt, Kris Carpenter, Carol Notaro, John Kirchman, Brett Bandy, Al Phillips, Jenny Jenners, Michael Cotten, Jennifer Wisniewski, Gene Thompson, Derick Mitchell, John Vansandt, John Somodi, Magpie Martele, Robb Redden, Dwain Cox, Jeff Sanders, Vincent Migliore, Steve Swan, Helen Bigler Starr, Jerry Overfelt, Stuart Lyons, Bob Matheson, Donald Van Handel, Bennie McDonald, Chris Mickles, Shawn Bullock, Quenton Cox, Jason Greene, Robert Edward Armidon, Duane Nollen, Philipp Mueller, Stephen Ray, Valerie McEntee, Steve Rose, Chris Ravn, Paula Brkich, Andrew Hill, Kathy Engel, Carlo Giuliano, Sarah Kostovic, Ryan M. Landry, Bob Bembridge, Robert Fiore, Denton A. Skipper, Scotty Creel, Bill Booth, Dexter Greene, Jim Reynolds, Doug Niebergall, Jeffrey A. Ward, J Street Hall, Jeffrey Stark, Colin Patrick Webb, Dennis Cravero, John Dina DC, Craig M Daly, Eric Fournier, Steve McHargue, Vacaru Vlad Gabriel, Dan Singleton, Seamus Cortés, Carolyn Burrell Jones, Joy Smiley, Joseph Alexander, Barbara Ann Knoebel, Allen Black, Chris Sotomayor, Christopher Brown, Byron Keith Buescher, Mike Jean Michel, Tim Deley, Daniel Fortune, Benny Harris, Carl Deconinck, Tony Sola, Eric T Singer, Zane Neumann, Jack Murdock, Wingate Barraclough, Mariusz Skrobała, Clay Dalton, Brian J Bagi, Ian Madewell, Thora Potts, Bob Sanders, Matthew Wingers, Wes Wheelock, Daniel Beegan liked this post