The Mind of Mr. Putin

The Mind of Mr. Putin

This post was viewed 27,677 times.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Votes: 4.75 Stars!
Share Pat's Columns!

By Patrick J. Buchanan

“Do you realize now what you have done?”

So Vladimir Putin in his U.N. address summarized his indictment of a U.S. foreign policy that has produced a series of disasters in the Middle East that we did not need the Russian leader to describe for us.

Fourteen years after we invaded Afghanistan, Afghan troops are once again fighting Taliban forces for control of Kunduz. Only 10,000 U.S. troops still in that ravaged country prevent the Taliban’s triumphal return to power.

A dozen years after George W. Bush invaded Iraq, ISIS occupies its second city, Mosul, controls its largest province, Anbar, and holds Anbar’s capital, Ramadi, as Baghdad turns away from us — to Tehran.

The cost to Iraqis of their “liberation”? A hundred thousand dead, half a million widows and fatherless children, millions gone from the country and, still, unending war.

How has Libya fared since we “liberated” that land? A failed state, it is torn apart by a civil war between an Islamist “Libya Dawn” in Tripoli and a Tobruk regime backed by Egypt’s dictator.

Then there is Yemen. Since March, when Houthi rebels chased a Saudi sock puppet from power, Riyadh, backed by U.S. ordinance and intel, has been bombing that poorest of nations in the Arab world.

Five thousand are dead and 25,000 wounded since March. And as the 25 million Yemeni depend on imports for food, which have been largely cut off, what is happening is described by one U.N. official as a “humanitarian catastrophe.”

“Yemen after five months looks like Syria after five years,” said the international head of the Red Cross on his return.

On Monday, the wedding party of a Houthi fighter was struck by air-launched missiles with 130 guests dead. Did we help to produce that?

What does Putin see as the ideological root of these disasters?

“After the end of the Cold War, a single center of domination emerged in the world, and then those who found themselves at the top of the pyramid were tempted to think they were strong and exceptional, they knew better.”

Then, adopting policies “based on self-conceit and belief in one’s exceptionality and impunity,” this “single center of domination,” the United States, began to export “so-called democratic” revolutions.

How did it all turn out? Says Putin:

“An aggressive foreign interference has resulted in a brazen destruction of national institutions. … Instead of the triumph of democracy and progress, we got violence, poverty and social disaster.

Nobody cares a bit about human rights, including the right to life.”

Is Putin wrong in his depiction of what happened to the Middle East after we plunged in? Or does his summary of what American interventions have wrought echo the warnings made against them for years by American dissenters?

Putin concept of “state sovereignty” is this: “We are all different, and we should respect that. No one has to conform to a single development model that someone has once and for all recognized as the right one.”

The Soviet Union tried that way, said Putin, and failed. Now the Americans are trying the same thing, and they will reach the same end.

Unlike most U.N. speeches, Putin’s merits study. For he not only identifies the U.S. mindset that helped to produce the new world disorder, he identifies a primary cause of the emerging second Cold War.

To Putin, the West’s exploitation of its Cold War victory to move NATO onto Russia’s doorstep caused the visceral Russian recoil. The U.S.-backed coup in Ukraine that overthrew the elected pro-Russian government led straight to the violent reaction in the pro-Russian Donbas.

What Putin seems to be saying to us is this:

If America’s elites continue to assert their right to intervene in the internal affairs of nations, to make them conform to a U.S. ideal of what is a good society and legitimate government, then we are headed for endless conflict. And, one day, this will inevitably result in war, as more and more nations resist America’s moral imperialism.

Nations have a right to be themselves, Putin is saying.

They have the right to reflect in their institutions their own histories, beliefs, values and traditions, even if that results in what Americans regard as illiberal democracies or authoritarian capitalism or even Muslim theocracies.

There was a time, not so long ago, when Americans had no problem with this, when Americans accepted a diversity of regimes abroad. Indeed, a belief in nonintervention abroad was once the very cornerstone of American foreign policy.

Wednesday and Thursday, Putin’s forces in Syria bombed the camps of U.S.-backed rebels seeking to overthrow Assad. Putin is sending a signal: Russia is willing to ride the escalator up to a collision with the United States to prevent us and our Sunni Arab and Turkish allies from dumping over Assad, which could bring ISIS to power in Damascus.

Perhaps it is time to climb down off our ideological high horse and start respecting the vital interests of other sovereign nations, even as we protect and defend our own.

Share Pat's Columns!
Max Ballotta, Debbie Jaynes, Timothy Selway, Gustavo Baretieri, Simon Michael Walker Reilly, Stephen Stafford, Oscar Saborío-Romano, Em Weirich, David Moore, Bernie Minor, Cynthia J. Starks, Bryan Doloresco, Vincent Migliore, Mark Oberhofer, Daniela Stancescu, Kevin Dolan, Scott Henderson, Bill Griffin, Paul AT Barros, Bennie McDonald, Eugene Girin, Mark Schember, Reinaldo Rivera, Gary Boberg, Elaine Keane Mills, Ruth Hadley, Eamon Campbell, Thomas Harris, Tomáš Břicháček, Sandy Gray Romero, Michael O'Flynn, Nancy McCutchin, Mark West, Helen McKenna Fullinwider, Charles Picerno, Erik O'Dalaigh, Stuart Lyons, Felipe Couto, Bishop Varghese Mathai, Achile Bourquin, Travis Duffie, Thomas Schepp, Dana Laviano, Barry Bruss, Craig M Daly, Renee Taraska, Bob Bembridge, Andrew Guerrero, John Somodi, Mike Clapper, Rick Miller, George Chachauri, Bailey Webb, Doug Niebergall, Scott Spencer, Terry Schoellkopf, Mia Biia, John Reiner, Cyril W. Koob, Heather Kaetzel Barnes, Richard A. Hamblen, Frank Carlozzi, Mike Fletcher, Mark O'Keefe, William Patterson, Alvin Greenwood, Burton James Bollinger, John Greene, Waldemar Mark Duszyk, Monte Poitevint, Larry Laird, Miguel Schroth, Bob Adams, Jeffrey A. Ward, Paul Richardson, Dan Baker, Brian O'Leary, Mickey Long, James Fiacra, Leinad Luap Emuh, Lyubomir Popov, Tommy Montgomery, Gene Tseplaev, Paul Nanson, Guilherme Pöttker, Rich Keal, Robert A Sinclair, John DiFiore, Ivan Biki, Moises Octavio, Erik Zikos, Andy Zenchak, Wei Wang, Eric Carlson, Valerie McEntee, Ryan T. Sawyer, Nathan Brown, Mark Dankof, Jim Bray, Ross S. Heckmann, Pal Yurich, Joe D'Agostino, Paul Daghlian, Linda A Parent, Sheryl A. Bilotta-Green, Ray Fencl, Thomas Hood, Pat Davis, Stefania West, Bernard Casey liked this post