The Donald & The La Raza Judge

This post was viewed 62,474 times.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Votes: 4.61 Stars!
Share Pat's Columns!

By Patrick J. Buchanan

Before the lynching of The Donald proceeds, what exactly was it he said about that Hispanic judge?

Stated succinctly, Donald Trump said U.S. District Judge Gonzalo Curiel, who is presiding over a class-action suit against Trump University, is sticking it to him. And the judge’s bias is likely rooted in the fact that he is of Mexican descent.

Can there be any defense of a statement so horrific?

Just this. First, Trump has a perfect right to be angry about the judge’s rulings and to question his motives. Second, there are grounds for believing Trump is right.

On May 27, Curiel, at the request of The Washington Post, made public plaintiff accusations against Trump University — that the whole thing was a scam. The Post, which Bob Woodward tells us has 20 reporters digging for dirt in Trump’s past, had a field day.

And who is Curiel?

An appointee of President Obama, he has for years been associated with the La Raza Lawyers Association of San Diego, which supports pro-illegal immigrant organizations.

Set aside the folly of letting Clinton surrogates like the Post distract him from the message he should be delivering, what did Trump do to be smeared by a bipartisan media mob as a “racist”?

He attacked the independence of the judiciary, we are told.

But Presidents Jefferson and Jackson attacked the Supreme Court, and FDR, fed up with New Deal programs being struck down, tried to “pack the court” by raising the number of justices to 15 if necessary.

Abraham Lincoln leveled “that eminent tribunal” in his first inaugural, and once considered arresting Chief Justice Roger Taney.

The conservative movement was propelled by attacks on the Warren Court. In the ’50s and ’60s, “Impeach Earl Warren!” was plastered on billboards and bumper stickers all across God’s country.

The judiciary is independent, but that does not mean that federal judges are exempt from the same robust criticism as presidents or members of Congress.

Obama himself attacked the Citizens United decision in a State of the Union address, with the justices sitting right in front of him.

But Trump’s real hanging offense was that he brought up the judge’s ancestry, as the son of Mexican immigrants, implying that he was something of a judicial version of Univision’s Jorge Ramos.

Apparently, it is now not only politically incorrect, but, in Newt Gingrich’s term, “inexcusable,” to bring up the religious, racial or ethnic background of a judge, or suggest this might influence his actions on the bench.

But these things matter.

Does Newt think that when LBJ appointed Thurgood Marshall, ex-head of the NAACP, to the Supreme Court, he did not think Marshall would bring his unique experience as a black man and civil rights leader to the bench?

Surely, that was among the reasons Marshall was appointed.

When Obama named Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court, a woman of Puerto Rican descent who went through college on affirmative action scholarships, did Obama think this would not influence her decision when it came to whether or not to abolish affirmative action?

“I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life,” Sotomayor said in a speech at Berkeley law school and in other forums.

Translation: Ethnicity matters, and my Latina background helps guide my decisions.

All of us are products of our family, faith, race and ethnic group. And the suggestion in these attacks on Trump that judges and justices always rise about such irrelevant considerations, and decide solely on the merits, is naive nonsense.

There are reasons why defense lawyers seek “changes of venue” and avoid the courtrooms of “hanging judges.”

When Obama reflexively called Sgt. Crowley “stupid” after Crowley’s 2009 encounter with that black professor at Harvard, and said of Trayvon Martin, “If I had a son, he’d look like Trayvon,” was he not speaking as an African-American, as well as a president?

Pressed by John Dickerson on CBS, Trump said it’s “possible” a Muslim judge might be biased against him as well.

Another “inexcusable” outrage.

But does anyone think that if Obama appointed a Muslim to the Supreme Court, the LGBT community would not be demanding of all Democratic Senators that they receive assurances that the Muslim judge’s religious views on homosexuality would never affect his court decisions, before they voted to put him on the bench?

When Richard Nixon appointed Judge Clement Haynsworth to the Supreme Court, it was partly because he was a distinguished jurist of South Carolina ancestry. And the Democrats who tore Haynsworth to pieces did so because they feared he would not repudiate his Southern heritage and any and all ideas and beliefs associated with it.

To many liberals, all white Southern males are citizens under eternal suspicion of being racists. The most depressing thing about this episode is to see Republicans rushing to stomp on Trump, to show the left how well they have mastered their liberal catechism.

Share Pat's Columns!
Chris Wade, Cecile E. Wheeler, Sergio Villalta, Catherine Humphries, Dawn Van Naam, Piotr Przybysz, Angi Stamm, Mike Widney, Sheryl A. Bilotta-Green, Kirby Brant, Bill Wagner, Tex Frezell, Philip Vogel, Marcos de Paula, Joseph Varada, Adam Spivey, Colleen Swan, Mark West, Dillon Master, Jesse K. Roberson, David Nicol, Beth Ellen Nagle, Michael Newkirk, გიორგი ჩაჩაური, Hermonta Godwin, Kim Daskam, Kevin Gruidl, James Speers, Genevieve Roberts, Rudolfa Wolfer, Dylan Bauer, Right Sampson, Marina Velichko Stadnitskiy, Phil Caulfield, Michele Harris Thompson Reed, Kenny Starling, Jim Murphy, Randy Hilzinger, Eugene Girin, Barry Willis, Vincent Migliore, Mary Ann Settle, Jeff Carlson, Thomas Ziegler, Carmine Basciano, David Brown, Steve Bas, Ralph Steven Newbill, Rhonda Wallace Menz, Paul Ferkul, Peggy McGuckin Smith, Nanette Niece, Teresa M Mangini, Carol Cooke Garner, Jason Michael Haberkorn, Tait Aune, Anne Ralston Kane, Leslie Rose, Lester Luahiwa, Carl Tommy Miller, Steve Glover, Alexandra Apostol, Cullum Roybal Rm, Al-Jane West, Shannon Woody, Penny Lee, Nicholas Stamates, Colette Wilson, Richard J Gagner, Robert Wold, Houston Smith, Leona Plato Coyne, Jon Ferrell, Greg Mussitsch, Lynn Hart, Andrew Arendoski, Dave Morse, Joe Murphy, Matthew C Sult, Jim Imes, Jason Corley, Dov Bechhofer, Lynn Richardson Baker, Maxine Gress, Michael Sandoz, Andrew Ziemba, Christopher Foley, Abigail Summar, Margaret Mary O'Connor, Betty Clark Edwards, Larry Miller, Brian Saul, Alethea Auge Loree, Otie Richenson, Kim Schweighart, Doug Niebergall, Bruce Buchanan, Brennan Doherty, Fred Stachura, Kent Clizbe, Rodney Allebach, Thomas J. Petro III, Rick Robin Paderes Cagnaan, James Gillett, Deborah Graham, Gene Farrell, Tracy Perina, Veronica Hayes, Stevan Novakovic, Tom Hardigree, Mitsuo Nakai, Andy McDuffie, Jeremy Pender, Paul Stewart, Duane Wood, Tammy Tapley, Charlene Danevicz Truszkowski, Janice Dee, Sven-Thorsten Ihde, Scott Tapley, Bob Bembridge, John Dina DC, JJ Roman, Karen Sirridge, Alan B. Busick, Mark McPherrin, Kristina Leggett, Ken Cratchley, Stephanie Boytek, K.A. Badynski, Reggie Cowan, Craig M Daly, Jerry Weber LaMar, Valerie McEntee, Thomas A. Blair, Mark O'Keefe, Frank Carlozzi, Taylor Norwitt, Jeffrey A. Ward, Bob McPherrin, Denton A. Skipper, Mark Zohan, Rahul Manchanda, Paul Richardson, James Borne, David LeVaughn, Eric Fournier, John Dempsey, TJ Duff, Dan Archer, David Piercy, Joshua Vig, Joanne Blakemore, John DiFiore, Dennis Cravero, Ralph Morelli, Stuart Watts, Betty Hill, Tee Murrpphy, Russell Kallio, Quenton Cox, Paolo Lavita, Mickey Long, Raymond Masterson, Charles Picerno, Cheryl Moone Martin, Richard Edwards, Graham Murray, David Mc, Phillip Bellini, Juster Paterno, Mike Grammont, Anita Crane, Sorin Dragan, Scott Sigel, Eric Robinson, Benny Harris, Robert William Kearney, Timour Paltashev, David M Deane, Jessica Frey, Daniel O' Connell, Diana King, Margo Beutel, Luis Miguel, Robert F. Harrold-Rees Turner-Hilliard II, Travis White, Carla John Nunley Rogers, Dean Baadsgaard, Dino Alvarez, Michael Stefani, John Vansandt, Birgit Ulrich Davis, John Elliott, Daniel Rotter, David Moore, Chris Dowson, Christian T. Geoppo, Richard Stover, Mary Ralya, Steve Forrest, Caroline Marie, An'e Finn, Erik O'Dalaigh, James Edmund Thomas Snow, Christopher J. Moffe, Luis Obispo, Eric Rogers, Gail Lee liked this post